I found Mulcair to be somewhat restrained (despite his reputation, deserved or otherwise, to be condescending and pugnacious), while Trudeau looked uncomfortable at times trying to deliver some rehearsed set pieces (those closing remarks, amirite?). Harper was... Harper. May appeared to rise above some of the pettiness and looked quite reasonable and thoughtful by comparison.
Who won the Maclean's debate? Why, the person you like, of course! Whose performance surprised and impressed you? That person you also like, but just a little less than that other person you like. Who lost? Well, I think you already know the answer to that...
Meanwhile, in America:
Screenshot from FOX News, via Gawker |